
This is Part 2 of a multi-part article series by Jennifer Thetford-Kay and Cathy Mudge of Protect and Teach. Part 1 followed the gradual expansion of the school’s role. The series examines how the role of UK schools has changed over the last 20–25 years. The authors challenge UK Government policies and aim to build a counter-narrative that could be used in future approaches to UK education. Watch the UK Column interview in which Jennifer and Cathy spoke with Professor Diane Rasmussen about this work.
Safeguarding was one of the streams flowing into it. But what exactly is safeguarding? Most of us think we know. A child is being abused, neglected, or seriously harmed, and the adults around that child have a duty to notice, act, and protect. Of course they do.
Yet open today’s safeguarding guidance, and the territory is much wider. It includes early help, mental health, attendance, online harms, radicalisation, peer behaviour, family circumstances, filtering, monitoring, and, increasingly, the information schools hold about people around the child. How did one word come to cover so much?
That question matters because ‘safeguarding’ is not an ordinary policy label. Say that something is a safeguarding concern and the temperature changes immediately. Records may be made, information may be shared, the Designated Safeguarding Lead may become involved, and outside agencies may be contacted. Before asking where safeguarding should go next, we need a more basic answer.
What did it originally mean, who widened it, and where does child protection end and the much larger safeguarding system begin?
The answer begins not with wellbeing, behaviour, or online safety, but with something much starker: cruelty.
So What Does Safeguarding Mean?
Here is the first difficulty: there is no single definition of ‘safeguarding’ written into any Act of Parliament.
The definition used across the current system comes instead from statutory guidance. Working Together to Safeguard Children 2026 describes safeguarding and promoting children’s welfare as an umbrella covering six broad areas: providing help and support when problems emerge, protecting children from maltreatment (including online), preventing impairment of their mental or physical health or development, ensuring safe and effective care, supporting their upbringing within their family network where possible, and taking action to enable them to achieve the best outcomes.
That is an extraordinarily wide territory. It reaches from protecting a child from abuse to providing early help, supporting health and development, providing family support, and improving outcomes.
Child protection is narrower. It sits within safeguarding and concerns particular children who are suspected of suffering, or likely to suffer, significant harm.
The distinction is crucial. Safeguarding is the umbrella; child protection is one part of it. Safeguarding itself is not a single legal threshold.
That was not always how the system was understood. For much of the 20th century, law and policy spoke separately about cruelty, abuse, protection, welfare, care, and prevention. The important question, therefore, is not simply when Britain began protecting children. It had been doing that for generations.
The question is how those different responsibilities came to be gathered beneath one increasingly powerful word, and what legal authority that word actually carries.
Long before anyone spoke of safeguarding, the language was protection from cruelty. The Prevention of Cruelty to, and Protection of, Children Act 1889 made cruelty an offence. It applied to a person over 16 with custody of a child who wilfully ill-treated, neglected, abandoned, or exposed that child in a way likely to cause “unnecessary suffering”. A cruelty offence survives today, in amended form, in section 1 of the Children and Young Persons Act 1933.
The Children Act 1908 consolidated and extended this protective framework, including provisions on infant-life protection and cruelty to children.
The National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (NSPCC) grew from the same tradition. Its Royal Charter is dated 28 May 1895, its registered objects still include preventing the “public and private wrongs of children”, and section 31 of the Children Act 1989 gave it unusual standing as an “authorised person” able to bring care proceedings.
Protection did not stand still after the Victorian period. The post-war system changed significantly following the 1946 Curtis Committee, which examined the care of children deprived of normal home life. Its recommendations led to the Children Act 1948. The Act brought central responsibility for such children together under the Home Office. It required local authorities to establish Children’s Committees with trained Children’s Officers responsible for children in their care.
The emphasis was also beginning to move beyond responding after harm had occurred. The Children and Young Persons Act 1963 strengthened the developing preventive role of local authorities, including assistance intended to prevent children from having to enter care.
That matters because prevention was not invented by modern safeguarding policy. Welfare, family support, and child protection all developed before ‘safeguarding’ became the organising term. What changed later was that these previously distinguishable functions increasingly came to sit beneath the same umbrella.
The modern multi-agency system developed much later, and one little girl’s death became a defining moment. Seven-year-old Maria Colwell died in 1973 after sustained abuse. She had already been known to public services. The Conservative Secretary of State for Social Services, Sir Keith Joseph, set up a committee of inquiry chaired by the barrister Thomas Field-Fisher QC. Its 1974 report exposed failures of communication between agencies that each held part of the picture.
In April 1974, the Department of Health and Social Security (DHSS) under Labour’s Barbara Castle issued a memorandum on non-accidental injury to children, circular LASSL(74)13. It was advice, not law, but it recommended Area Review Committees and invited them to consider keeping central records of injured or at-risk children. By 1976, the Government reported that only a few of the 100 committees had not set up such records. Much of what we now think of as modern safeguarding, including multi-agency working, information exchange, and registers, was already being built inside a much narrower child protection framework. The later safeguarding system inherited that machinery.
A second landmark exposed the opposite danger. In July 1987, the Minister for Health, Tony Newton, announced a statutory inquiry into the handling of suspected child abuse in Cleveland, and Mrs Justice Butler-Sloss agreed to lead it. When her report was published, Newton told the Commons on 6 July 1988 that protecting children must be achieved in a way that “does not trample on the rights of parents and inflict unnecessary distress on the very children we wish to be helped”. Child protection has always had to balance two risks: failing to intervene when a child is genuinely in danger, and intervening unjustifiably in family life.
That same day, Newton announced “comprehensive guidance” from his department and the Welsh Office, with circulars to the police and the education service. The first Working Together guide appeared that year, its subtitle describing arrangements for inter-agency cooperation “for the protection of children from abuse”.
Then came the Children Act 1989. It used the verb ‘safeguard’ without defining any policy category called safeguarding. Section 17 gave local authorities a duty to “safeguard and promote the welfare” of children in need. Section 47 required enquiries where there was reasonable cause to suspect a child was suffering, or likely to suffer, significant harm. Those duties fell on local authorities, not schools, and the 1991 edition of Working Together, issued by the Home Office and other departments, kept that focus on “the protection of children from abuse”.
By the late 1990s, however, the language was changing. In June 1996, the Conservative Health Secretary, Stephen Dorrell, asked Sir William Utting, a former Chief Inspector of the Social Services Inspectorate, to review the safeguards for children living away from home. His report, People Like Us, was published on 19 November 1997. A later joint Chief Inspectors’ report credited Utting with describing safeguarding as a distinct activity involving “taking proactive steps to keep children safe.” Child protection asks: is this particular child being harmed? A preventative safeguarding model asks another question too: what can institutions do before that happens? That is a much larger field.
The change was subtle but profound: safeguarding was no longer only about responding to identifiable harm, but increasingly about anticipating risk.
In 1999, the Department of Health, the Home Office, and the Department for Education and Employment, then led by David Blunkett, renamed the principal inter-agency guidance Working Together to Safeguard Children. It said schools could help prevent abuse through their policies and curriculum. Yet nobody had actually said what ‘safeguarding’ meant.
A Duty before a Definition
Parliament acted first. Section 175 of the Education Act 2002, which received Royal Assent on 24 July 2002 while Estelle Morris was Secretary of State for Education and Skills, required local education authorities and maintained-school governing bodies to exercise their functions “with a view to safeguarding and promoting the welfare of children”. It also required them to “have regard to” guidance from the Secretary of State.
Three months later, in October 2002, eight inspectorates published their first joint report, . They covered social services, schools, health, police, probation, prisons, the courts, and prosecutors, and Ofsted’s Chief Inspector at the time was David Bell, a name we will meet again. Their admission could hardly have been clearer:
“The term safeguarding has not been defined in law or government guidance.”
The concept, the inspectors said, had ‘evolved’ from concern about children in public care to include the protection from harm of all children and the work of all agencies. So they wrote a working definition themselves: agencies should take “all reasonable measures to ensure that the risks of harm to children’s welfare are minimised”, and act when concerns arose. The first working definition was not written by Parliament. It was written by inspectors.
The chronology is striking. Parliament had created a safeguarding duty before anyone had settled what safeguarding meant. Section 175 then came into force in England on 1 June 2004, and its practical content would be supplied by guidance. In September 2004, the Department for Education and Skills (DfES), then led by Charles Clarke, published Safeguarding Children in Education. It adopted the inspectors’ working definition, and then widened it. Safeguarding, it said, “covers more than the contribution made to child protection in relation to individual children”. Under the heading now sat health and safety, bullying, medical needs, first aid, school security, and drugs and substance misuse.
Schools had always dealt with first aid and bullying; what changed was that these responsibilities now sat beneath a new and increasingly powerful label. The expansion happened by addition rather than replacement. Child protection remained, while new concerns accumulated around it.
Law, Guidance, or Policy?
This is where the language can become misleading. Something described as a ‘safeguarding requirement’ may rest on very different kinds of authority.
An Act of Parliament is law. Section 175 of the Education Act 2002, for example, requires maintained-school governing bodies to make arrangements, so their functions are exercised with a view to safeguarding and promoting children’s welfare. It also requires them to have regard to guidance issued by the Secretary of State.
Statutory guidance is not the same thing as an Act, although bodies within its scope must take it seriously and, where legislation requires it, have regard to it. KCSIE itself distinguishes between things a school ‘must’ do because there is a legal duty and things it ‘should’ do unless there is good reason not to. Government guidance elsewhere makes the same distinction between legal duties, statutory guidance and non-statutory recommendations.
Non-statutory guidance and local policy sit lower still. They may represent good practice or organisational expectations, but they do not acquire the force of statute merely because they appear beneath a safeguarding heading.
For teachers and parents, those distinctions can easily disappear in practice. Bullying, first aid, and abuse can all appear beneath the same heading, even though they do not carry the same seriousness, threshold, or response. The word ‘safeguarding’ carries urgency. Yet the correct question is not simply: Is this safeguarding? It is also: what is the source of the requirement, who does it bind, and what does it actually authorise?
Meanwhile, another child’s death was changing the climate. Victoria Climbié, born near Abidjan in Côte d’Ivoire, died in a London hospital on 25 February 2000, aged eight, after what Lord Laming called “months of appalling ill-treatment at the hands of two individuals who were supposed to be caring for her”. In April 2001, the Health Secretary, Alan Milburn, and the Home Secretary, Jack Straw, appointed Laming to lead the statutory inquiries into her death. His report, published in January 2003 and addressed to Milburn and the Home Secretary, David Blunkett, made 108 recommendations, including alerting education authorities when a child was not attending school. The problem was exposed by Maria Colwell’s death 30 years earlier: professionals each held fragments of information, but no one necessarily saw the whole picture.
The Government’s response went much further. The September 2003 Green Paper Every Child Matters, presented by the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, organised policy for all children around five outcomes: being healthy, staying safe, enjoying and achieving, making a positive contribution, and achieving economic wellbeing. “Staying safe” was only one of them. Carrying it forward fell to Margaret Hodge, in the newly created post of Minister for Children, who presented the Children Bill to the Commons in September 2004.
The Children Act 2004 then turned parts of that architecture into law. Its section 11 required bodies such as local authorities, health bodies, and police to make arrangements to safeguard and promote children’s welfare. Schools were not listed; the section expressly excluded education functions already covered by section 175. Section 10 created a separate duty to cooperate to improve children’s wellbeing, and schools became “relevant partners” for that only in January 2010, through section 193 of the Apprenticeships, Skills, Children and Learning Act 2009.
Those distinctions matter. A wellbeing duty is not a section 11 safeguarding duty, and a school’s section 175 duty is not a local authority’s section 47 child protection duty. Yet all increasingly sat inside one children’s services system. So who was changing safeguarding? Parliament created some of the duties. Government departments filled in others through guidance. Inspectorates then interpreted the developing framework, while schools had to turn it into day-to-day practice. Safeguarding was not rewritten in one moment; its meaning accumulated.
A formal government definition arrived through statutory guidance, not an Act. Statutory guidance issued under section 11 of the Children Act 2004 in 2005 defined safeguarding and promoting welfare in terms of protecting children from maltreatment, preventing impairment of health or development, ensuring safe and effective care, and enabling children to have optimum life chances. The 2006 edition of Working Together to Safeguard Children, published in April 2006 while Ruth Kelly was Education Secretary, carried that definition into the principal inter-agency guidance and made the relationship explicit: child protection was only ‘a part of’ safeguarding, concerned with specific children suffering, or likely to suffer, significant harm. Safeguarding had become the larger category.
A month later, Alan Johnson replaced Kelly at the DfES, and under him the department carried the definition into schools through , issued in November 2006 and in force from January 2007.
On 10 June 2010, Education Secretary Michael Gove and Children and Families Minister Tim Loughton asked Professor Eileen Munro to review child protection. Her 2011 report warned that the system had become “over-bureaucratised and concerned with compliance”. Yet when Gove’s Department for Education (DfE) rewrote in 2013, the definition became broader, not narrower.
The old purpose became a fourth defining element: “taking action to enable all children to have the best outcomes”. The purpose of safeguarding had become part of its definition. In 2014, still under Gove, the first Keeping Children Safe in Education (KCSIE) appeared.
The 2023 edition of , published in December 2023 while Gillian Keegan was Education Secretary, expressly added help and support “as soon as problems emerge”. It also brought in maltreatment “including online”, mental health, kinship care, and outcomes from the Children’s Social Care National Framework. The current , published on 18 March 2026 under Bridget Phillipson, retains that broad conception. Meanwhile, section 47 still centres statutory child protection on significant harm. The protective core did not disappear; it became the centre of a much wider framework.
KCSIE shows the same accumulation, edition by edition, each issued under a named Secretary of State. Under Nicky Morgan, the 2015 update reflected the new Prevent duty and added more on female genital mutilation. The duty itself came from section 26 of the Counter-Terrorism and Security Act 2015, whose bill the Home Secretary, Theresa May, introduced in November 2014. It has applied to schools since 1 July 2015. Under Damian Hinds, KCSIE 2018 introduced contextual safeguarding and a new part on sexual violence and harassment between children, and an annex spoke of “a whole school or college approach to safeguarding and online safety”. Under Gavin Williamson, KCSIE 2020 made explicit that “both mental and physical health are relevant to safeguarding”, and KCSIE 2021 gave the “whole school and college approach to safeguarding” a section of its own.
Taken separately, each change had an obvious rationale. Read in sequence, they show the safeguarding frame steadily encompassing more areas of school life.
Under Gillian Keegan, KCSIE 2023 added filtering and monitoring standards while insisting they were “not a new burden”. Under Bridget Phillipson, DfE’s own change table for KCSIE 2025 said the guidance had been updated to clarify that misinformation, disinformation, and conspiracy theories “are safeguarding harms”. Encountering a false claim online is plainly not equivalent to abuse. KCSIE 2026, published in July 2026, reaches further into generative artificial intelligence and mobile phones. The guidance occasionally sets limits too: schools “should not initiate any action regarding social transition” for a child questioning their gender unless a child or parent has asked. Even so, the pattern is unmistakable. The definition continued to gather new meanings over time.
The definition also travels across sectors. On 23 October 2026, Ofsted updated its own safeguarding policy specifically to bring its definition into line with . Government guidance defines, school guidance embeds, inspectors adopt, training reproduces, and schools experience the result as safeguarding.
Charities form part of that ecosystem too, and the NSPCC’s history almost mirrors the history of the word. By 1999, its Full Stop campaign included “the child in the school” among its five themes and aimed to get child protection onto the curriculum. In 2021, Williamson’s DfE arranged for the NSPCC to run a dedicated helpline for reporting abuse in education. Its 2025 policy plan supports “high-quality and inclusive” Relationships, Sex and Health Education, describing it as having “an important role to play in safeguarding children”.
That does not make the NSPCC the author of government safeguarding policy, nor is it evidence of improper influence. It does show mission expansion. A charity founded to confront cruelty now operates throughout a safeguarding system whose own meaning has expanded far beyond cruelty.
The two graphics below show that development at a glance: who changed safeguarding, what kind of authority each change carried, and how the framework widened from cruelty and child protection into the much broader system schools work within today.