
Arguments from the Yes camp — that Iceland, as a member of the European Economic Area, already has to adopt many rules it has no say in shaping, or that the euro could bring down the country’s punishing cost of living — fell on deaf ears. The security dimension, which the government had cited as one reason for holding the referendum, also remained peripheral to the debate.
“For the No camp, everything came down to a single issue,” says Hallgrímur Oddsson, founder of the European think tank Evrópustraumar: “Icelandic fisheries, and how they would fit into the Common Fisheries Policy, where decisions are shared with 27 other countries.”
The EU’s signals in the run-up that it was willing to compromise on fisheries clearly failed to sway voters. Part of the No camp did not believe Iceland could hold its own at the negotiating table. Another part opposes membership on principle, whatever any accession deal might have contained.
Accordingly, it was the rural regions that pushed back hardest against new talks. In the northwest, a region shaped by farming and fishing, almost 63 percent voted no. Only the two constituencies of the capital, Reykjavík, delivered a Yes majority — and even there it was slimmer than supporters had hoped.
The final poll before the vote also suggested that younger voters, in particular, may have turned against accession talks. In June, nearly two-thirds of 18- to 29-year-olds said they were likely to vote Yes; by late August, only 40 percent did.
“The No side sold the referendum as though it were already about membership itself, rather than about resuming negotiations,” says Maximilian Conrad, a political scientist and EU expert at the University of Iceland in Reykjavík.