Stephen Goss: Labour has failed to resolve Northern Ireland’s legacy problem

In the ‘’ section of the Belfast Agreement, paragraphs 11 and 12 acknowledged and promised to address ‘the suffering of the victims of violence as a necessary element of reconciliation’. Signatories also committed to the ‘provision of services that are supportive and sensitive to the needs of victims’. Almost 30 years on from the Agreement, no one is satisfied with how these pledges have been implemented.

In September last year I argued that the last Government’s Legacy Act had failed by prioritising finality over justice. Families could hardly be expected to accept that establishing what had happened to a murdered relative – or that those responsible should be punished – had expired because Westminster felt it was time to draw a line and move on.

Scrapping the Act was a Labour manifesto pledge. The current Government’s subsequent Northern Ireland Troubles Bill passed the Commons on 20th October and awaits its Lords Second Reading on 2nd December. However, tearing up a bad law is the easy part. This Bill restores rights while leaving the hardest questions unanswered.

The Legacy Act sent cases to a newly created Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery (ICRIR). It halted inquests, restricted civil litigation, and offered conditional immunity to anyone who gave an account of their own Troubles-related offences. The current Bill abolishes the immunity scheme and lifts the bar on civil claims. It keeps the ICRIR but renames it the ‘Legacy Commission’, giving it wider investigative powers, conflict-of-interest safeguards, and statutory representation for victims and survivors.

It lets halted inquests resume before coroners. Others become judge-led inquisitorial proceedings inside the Commission, with family participation, public hearings, and arrangements for sensitive evidence. The Bill creates a separate Independent Commission on Information Retrieval (ICIR). In keeping with Labour’s instincts, yet another public body is to be established – but we save on a consonant. Information supplied to the ICIR, and evidence derived from it, cannot be used in legal proceedings. However, contributors remain liable to prosecution if evidence of their offences are otherwise obtained.

The ban on new legacy inquests remains, and families’ choice of route is still constrained. Renaming the Commission is not the same as replacing it. This is a refacing of the inherited machinery, not a new design.

The Bill also addresses earlier controversies. Its ‘on the run’ letters clause clarifies assurances issued to individuals – principally republican suspects – that they were not now wanted by police. Although these were not formal pardons, an erroneous assurance led to the collapse of the prosecution of John Downey over the 1982 Hyde Park bombing. The Bill would prevent prosecutions being halted on grounds founded on such letters.

Amendments have strengthened the Bill’s safeguards for veterans, including protection against unnecessary repetition of investigations. There are provisions for evidence to be provided remotely, requests for anonymity, and consideration of witnesses’ health. The Bill also expressly – and rightly –distinguishes lawful action in the course of duty from action taken for terrorist purposes.

Veterans should certainly not face repeated investigations. These safeguards are supposed to prevent that. Yet, protecting former soldiers from needless scrutiny should not extend to shielding them from credible allegations of unlawful killing. To do so would weaken the very rule of law they served to uphold.

This raises countless questions. How should the law distinguish between a reasonable decision taken in seconds under fire and a criminal act? What weight should be given to the orders, intelligence, and rules of engagement under which personnel operated? How should responsibility be apportioned between those who pulled the trigger and those who placed them in that situation?

Amongst the contentious additions are requirements for the Attorney General’s consent for serious Troubles-related prosecutions. The Northern Ireland Secretary has denied this is an amnesty for veterans. Putting a ministerial law officer into prosecution decisions creates an obvious confidence problem – however firmly ministers insist the role is legal rather than political. In Northern Ireland, perception is half the battle.

The Northern Irish parties are split. The SDLP and Alliance supported it in the Commons; the DUP, Ulster Unionists, and TUV opposed it. Sinn Féin called the amendments a ‘veterans’ charter’. The SDLP and Alliance criticised the Attorney General’s role while backing the Bill in general. Unionists cite inadequate protection for those who served, doubts about Dublin’s genuine co-operation, and too little time to scrutinise extensive amendments. Ulster Unionist MP Robin Swann has pressed the fact that the many victims of Troubles-related sexual violence are excluded from consideration.

None of these concerns reduces the debate to nationalists versus unionists.

Nor do victims speak with one voice. Nearly 200 bereaved families, writing through Relatives for Justice and the Pat Finucane Centre, warn that a mechanism tilted towards veterans will not command their confidence. Their relatives were killed by the Army, UDR, or RUC, and they want those deaths properly scrutinised. Victims’ Commissioner Joe McVey welcomed the new bilateral framework, but rightly rejects the pitting of veterans against victims. The families of murdered soldiers and police officers are victims’ families too. They need investigations that establish responsibility for their loved ones murdered doing their duty.

In addition, there remain significant gaps in the new legislation. The Legacy Commission’s remit will end on 10th April 1998 – thereby excluding one of the most shocking Troubles tragedies: the Omagh bombing. Omagh has its own inquiry, but the cut-off is difficult to explain to families whose loss came after the Agreement.

There are, of course, national security considerations involved. Retaining information on the basis of national security is essential for protecting sources and lives. However, it should not become a convenient shield for institutional reputations. A process that investigates alleged state wrongdoing while letting the state decide what families see starts with a credibility deficit. Stronger powers to obtain files mean little if the answers remain locked away.

Corresponding Irish legislation is needed to give access to government, Garda, and Defence Forces information. It is acknowledged that the security services collaborated with loyalist paramilitaries; there is also damning evidence of Irish collusion with the IRA. Accountability cannot stop at the border – any more than the terrorists did.

Above all, the system needs resources. The reports that the ICRIR has 189 operational staff against an assessed requirement of more than 400. Over 200 investigations are already under way or in preparation. Chairman of the ICRIR, Sir Declan Morgan (Former Lord Chief Justice of Northern Ireland) has warned that failure to provide the necessary resources will bring demands for numerous – expensive – public inquiries.

All of this has to be dealt with in the currently poisoned atmosphere at Stormont. The survival of the institutions remains on the brink. Legacy legislation does not float above that politics; it is an element of it and might well be hijacked for local political purposes.

Unionists and Conservatives are right to insist on fair treatment for veterans, credible investigation of terrorist crimes, enforceable Irish co-operation, and proper scrutiny of state wrongdoing. Labour has re-opened doors that the Legacy Act closed. However, without genuine independence, full disclosure, and a Commission staffed and resourced to do the work before witnesses die, Labour will have replaced one closed door with another – merely repainted.

Original source Stephen Goss: Labour has failed to resolve Northern Ireland’s legacy problem

Back to home