Revisiting Democrats’ potential 2028 ‘Tim Problem’

The 2026 midterms went beyond the Democrats’ more optimistic expectations. Not only have they won House and Senate majorities and state trifectas (control of state governorships and legislatures), but they also flipped deep-red seats that were not even on their radar, such as South Carolina and Mississippi’s Senate seats and the governorship of Texas. With these victories, it is hoped that Democrats could rein-in the Trump administration through investigations, the power of the purse and even impeachments, and perhaps even enact the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact to effectively bypass the Electoral College.

Although counting in Alaska’s run-off Senate election and some close House races continues, all eyes are now on the 2028 election. The ‘shellacking’ that the Republicans received and the ‘blue tsunami’ that Democrats rode in on has upended the contest, with the surefire candidacies of JD Vance and Marco Rubio now in doubt and Jon Ossoff now considered a serious contender.

Last April, I wrote a piece suggesting how the Democrats could avoid repeating their ‘Tim problem’ – referring to Tim Kaine and Tim Walz – in 2028. With the midterm results having spawned a wider pool of potential VP nominees (and my previous article having made one or two erroneous predictions – sorry, Senator El-Sayed), I thought it best to revisit this issue.

As US Senator from Virginia and Governor of Minnesota respectively, both Tims represented safe blue states, giving neither of their tickets an advantage in the Electoral College by not explicitly appealing to the swing states needed to win. Democrats now have a wealth of Southerners and Midwesterners to choose from: Senators Talarico of Texas, Cooper of North Carolina, Andrews of South Carolina, Turek of Iowa, Colom of Mississippi and Brown of Ohio; Governors Hinojosa of Texas, Bottoms of Georgia, Crowley of Wisconsin, Acton of Ohio and Ford of Nevada. Any one of these prospectives would help buoy a ticket headed by a blue-state Democrat like AOC, Newsom or Harris. Alternatively, with Southerners including Ossoff and Beshar tipped for the nomination, would two Southerners on the ticket – a Clinton-Gore 2.0 – or a Southern/Midwestern balance impact Democratic support in New York and California?

As amiable white men, both Tims were meant to be ‘inoffensive’ and balance out tickets headed by women. With many Americans sceptical of the idea of a female President and both Hilary Clinton and Kamala Harris having lost to Donald Trump, it is suggested that the Democrats must select a male candidate to avoid undue risk, manifesting a field with only Harris, AOC and Whitmer as female candidates. A female and-or minority ethnic running mate would be a prerequisite to fielding a ‘safe’ white, male candidate – like Sharpio or Pritzker – to demonstrate a commitment to communities harmed by the Trump administration.

As ‘safe’ candidates, both Tims failed to sufficiently energise their party’s base or persuade swing voters in a national contest. While Democrats were able to win in deep-red states, this was arguably the result of a ‘red drag’ with voters actively punishing Republicans inter alia for inflation and draconian immigration enforcement, and overtly Christian, even ex-Republican candidates happening to reap the rewards. As shown by Colom’s ‘Pick Another Protein? Pick Another Senator” campaign, a running mate must be an effective campaigner, especially outside Democratic hinterlands.

Experience may be a contentious issue. Prior gubernatorial experience would prepare someone who could become President at a time of crisis – as had happened to nine out of the fifteen VPs who went on to be President – while a senatorial background would be essential for someone who may become the President of the Senate. Gubernatorial and senatorial experience come with their own drawbacks, the freshman status of newly elected Democrats may benefit Senators over Governors. New Senators contradicting the chamber’s reputation for ‘experienced elders’ and keen to reform its sclerotic nature may bolster the ‘change’ credentials of a ticket; new Governors cannot be seen to abandon their state midterm. With Democrats’ gubernatorial victories last November, several Senate Democrats could run on the 2028 ticket without fear of potentially relinquishing their seat to the Republicans.

As I have said before, this will be a difficult balancing act, with a potential running mate unlikely to embody every single criterion and their suitability being heavily dependent on who the nominee is. It may well even be shaped by the GOP primaries, as they may produce an unforeseen candidate sufficiently distanced from Trump or result in a bear fight between its different wings. When all said and done, we may wish any Democratic ticket every success if it means ending the chaos wrought by MAGA.

* Samuel James Jackson is the Chair of the Policy Committee of the Yorkshire and the Humber Liberal Democrats and had served as the Liberal Democratic candidate in Halifax during the 2024 general election.

Original source Revisiting Democrats’ potential 2028 ‘Tim Problem’

Back to home