Reva Gudi: No ID is required for NHS care, but GP receptionists should not be immigration officials

My Practice Manager looked hassled.

“What’s the matter?” I asked.

“I’ve just had an earful from a lady whom we recently registered. I asked her for ID and proof of address, as we do with all those who want to register. She checked the NHS website and left saying she’s going to make an official complaint because, according to the NHS, she isn’t required to provide either”

Under the current rules, anyone in England, including an overseas visitor, can register with and consult an NHS GP without charge and does not need to be ordinarily resident. NHS guidance states: “You do not need ID, proof of address, or proof of immigration status.” These documents may be requested, but registration cannot be declined simply because they are not produced. As a practice, we abide by those rules.

Experience has taught me that being assertive about requesting documentation can result in correspondence involving NHS authorities, patient groups and the practice – with the practice ultimately reminded that documentation cannot be required.

The guidance is clear. What I find difficult to justify is the behind it.

I work as a GP serving a vibrant, diverse, mobile population near transport links and employment hubs. Questions of identity, residence and entitlement are part of the practical reality of running a GP practice.

Getting the Basics Right

Healthcare, like good government, depends on getting the basics right.

GP records contain some of the most sensitive information held about any of us. Patients can register with a GP practice in person or online.

We recently registered a patient online whose name and date of birth matched the information we received, but the electronic medical record transferred to us through the GP2GP  turned out to belong to someone else. Resolving it took considerable staff time, but the greater concern was patient safety and confidentiality. The wrong medical history could have been relied upon clinically, and another patient’s records potentially made accessible online.

NHS guidance recognises that documentation can help ensure patients are correctly matched and previous medical records reach the right practice. Yet online registration can proceed without documentary identity verification. If GP surgeries are expected to protect confidential information and maintain accurate records, asking for reasonable evidence that someone is who they say they are is not bureaucracy. It is basic information governance.

Somebody without conventional proof of address should not be denied registration simply because they cannot produce it. Safeguards must exist for people who are homeless, vulnerable or genuinely unable to produce documentation.

But a system where even these basic facts are not a requirement is difficult to describe as robust.

Confidentiality is one reason to establish who a patient is.

There is another important question worth asking: are they entitled to receive that care at the taxpayer’s expense?

The Principle of Reciprocity

When I travel abroad, I buy travel insurance or am prepared to self-fund. I make a simple assumption: if I become ill while visiting another country, I cannot expect its taxpayers to pay for my healthcare. There is no reason why short-term visitors to England should not make the same assumption if the same rules applied here.

Eligible visitors covered by reciprocal arrangements can access certain NHS treatment, while equivalent arrangements allow UK residents to access healthcare abroad.

We routinely prove who we are when opening a bank account or renting a property. Why should there be virtually no equivalent expectation when accessing NHS general practice?

The Inconsistency at the Heart of the System

With hospital care, emergency and immediately necessary treatment remains free for everyone. Beyond that, short-term overseas visitors who are not exempt or covered by a reciprocal agreement are chargeable at 150 per cent of the NHS tariff for the care they receive.

General practice is different.  Anybody in England may register and consult a GP without charge regardless of residence status. However, registration of short-term visitors does not establish entitlement to free hospital treatment.

The two systems run on different rules.

That distinction is increasingly hard to defend when general practice is under pressure. NHS England’s figures show 63.4 million registered patients in June 2026 and 30 million appointments in May alone.

A GP appointment is not an unlimited resource. Somebody pays for every consultation, prescription, referral or follow-up – ultimately, the taxpayer.

NHS care may be free at the point of use, but it is never free to provide.

This is Not an Argument About Immigration

This is not an argument about immigration. It is about entitlement, fairness and responsible stewardship of a finite resource.

People coming to Britain on many longer-term visas already pay the Immigration Health Surcharge – £1,035 a year for a standard adult, which raised £2.6 billion in 2024 – and can generally access NHS services on the same basis as an ordinarily resident person. Short-term visitors generally do not pay it.

So why should short-term visitors be treated differently?

British citizens travelling abroad are routinely advised to get travel insurance, and visitors to the UK are advised the same. If hospitals can charge overseas visitors in defined circumstances, why should primary care sit outside this principle?

Measuring the Problem Properly

Would collecting payments from overseas visitors cost more than it raises?

Perhaps. But that is an argument for understanding the scale of the problem, not ignoring it.

More than a decade after the Government commissioned work on visitor and migrant use of the NHS in 2013, we still lack a clear measure of what short-term visitors cost general practice because we do not routinely collect the information needed. Government considered extending overseas visitor charging to some GP services over a decade ago, but GP consultations remained free partly because of concerns that charging might deter people from seeking care.

The concern is legitimate. But protecting access to care does not require us to abandon reasonable rules around registration, entitlement or cost recovery.

So, start with the evidence. Establish a consistent way of identifying and recording short-term visitor status so we can understand how many use primary care, what services they use and at what cost. That would establish whether the sums are negligible or substantial, and whether cost recovery makes economic sense.

There may also be a wider effort worth measuring. If short -term visitors know they are responsible for the cost of primary care, some may choose to use the private sector or seek private GP care independently instead, reducing both the administrative burden of cost recovery and pressure on NHS general practice.

But the case for reform does not rest on sums alone.

Public confidence matters, and so do rigour and discipline in the stewardship of public money.

Clear National Rules, Not Border Policing at Reception

The answer is to turn GP receptionists into immigration officers. Rules on registration, entitlement and cost recovery should be clear, national and centrally administered.

Where appropriate, the NHS should be able to recover the cost from a short-term visitor, their insurer or their home country under a reciprocal agreement.

As a doctor, if somebody in front of me is genuinely ill, my first instinct is to treat them, not ask who is paying. But treating first and establishing who ultimately bears the cost are not incompatible.

Care can come first, with eligibility and payment dealt with afterwards. Safeguards must exist for vulnerable patients unable to produce documents immediately. Those are safeguards, not reasons to avoid reform.

Common Sense, Not a Choice Between Compassion and Responsibility

I have spent my working life as a GP trying to make access to healthcare easier, not harder. I do not want receptionists policing borders, vulnerable people frightened away from surgeries or doctors deciding who deserves treatment.

None of what I propose requires choosing between compassion and financial responsibility. It requires common sense: treat people when they need treatment, establish entitlement fairly and recover costs where they are properly due.

My Practice Manager and receptionists should not have to face harsh words and complaints simply for doing the responsible thing – asking for documentation. As a practice, we are occasionally reminded by patients, often pointedly, that they pay their taxes.

The principle cuts both ways.

The NHS has a responsibility towards its patients and is accountable to the taxpayer. It must stay true to both.

Original source Reva Gudi: No ID is required for NHS care, but GP receptionists should not be immigration officials

Back to home