Matthew Elliott: SEND Matters – that’s why protecting specialist education must be part of the reform agenda

Lord Elliott of Mickle Fell was a member of the recent House of Lords Autism Act 2009 Committee.

If there are few issues in British politics that should transcend party loyalties, then surely the future of children with special educational needs and disabilities is one of them?

This was the message when I had the pleasure of hosting the official launch of the SEND Matters Coalition in the House of Lords this week. The event brought together parents, campaigners, educators, professionals and an impressive cross-section of Parliament, with 48 parliamentarians registered, including 38 MPs and 10 peers.

The political breadth was striking. Labour was represented by Minister for Children and Families Georgia Gould, alongside MPs including Kate Osborne, John McDonnell, Helen Hayes, Tan Dhesi, Laura Kyrke-Smith and Jen Craft. The Conservative contingent included Saqib Bhatti, David Davis, James Cleverly and Greg Smith, Liberal Democrats Chris Coghlan, Al Pinkerton, Lee Dillon and Caroline Voaden were among those attending, alongside Reform UK’s Suella Braverman and Mayor Andrea Jenkyns were also there.

Peers including Lord Alton, Baroness Browning, Lord Addington, Lord Clement-Jones, Baroness Morris, Baroness Pidgeon and Lord Hampton added to the Parliamentary breadth of the occasion.

This was not simply a Westminster gathering.

The event brought together organisations representing parents and children, specialist educators and those working across the SEND sector. Among those represented were IPSEA, the British Dyslexia Association, the National Deaf Children’s Society and Anna Kennedy Online. We were also delighted to have the support of comedian and broadcaster Rory Bremner, a longstanding advocate for people with ADHD.

The Coalition exists for a straightforward reason: every child with SEND deserves the opportunity to fulfil their potential. Achieving that requires us to be honest about what is working, what is failing and what needs to change. There is much to welcome in the Government’s ambition to improve early identification and strengthen support in mainstream schools. Better support earlier in a child’s educational journey can make an enormous difference. It can prevent difficulties escalating, help children remain engaged in learning and give families greater confidence in the system.

However, there is an equally important principle that must not be overlooked: one size will never fit all. For some children, mainstream education, even with substantially improved support, will not meet their needs. Some have experienced placement breakdowns, exclusion or lengthy periods out of education. Others have complex and overlapping needs requiring a level of expertise and individual support that cannot simply be replicated in every mainstream classroom.

For these children, specialist education can be transformative. It can provide the stability, environment and expertise that allows them to re-engage with learning, develop confidence and begin to see a future for themselves. Protecting specialist provision is therefore not about defending a particular type of school, an organisation or a provider. It is about protecting the capacity of the education system to meet the needs of every child.

This matters enormously as the Government develops its SEND reforms. Specialist schools are already oversubscribed. If places close or capacity is lost while a new system is still being designed and implemented, where will the children who need that provision go? We cannot spend the next ten years building something better for the future while allowing a generation of children with the most complex needs to fall through the cracks in the meantime.

There is also a compelling economic argument for getting this right. Having founded the TaxPayers’ Alliance, I have always believed that public spending should be judged by the outcomes it delivers, not simply the amount it costs. It is easy to look at specialist education and see only the immediate expenditure. But the more important question is what happens if we fail to make that investment.

Research by Sonnet Impact suggests that appropriate provision for a child with complex SEND can generate at least £380,000 in lifetime value to society, after accounting for the cost of education. That value comes from giving young people a better chance of remaining in education, moving into employment and living more independently.

The alternative can be enormously expensive, both financially and socially. The average annual cost of a teenager in a young offenders’ institution is around £180,000. Failure to provide the right support early enough can have consequences that extend well beyond the education system, affecting families, public services and the criminal justice system. This is an invest-to-save argument in the truest sense. As my grandmother used to say, a stitch in time saves nine.

It is why I believe so strongly that we must listen to families. Parents are often the people who know their children best. They understand the challenges they face, the support that works and the consequences when the system fails them. Their experience must be central to the design of any new arrangements.

There will naturally be differences of opinion about how reform should be delivered but there should be no disagreement about the objective: a system that identifies needs earlier, supports families better and ensures that every child has access to the right educational environment.

SEND Matters is an opportunity to build a constructive coalition around that objective. We want to work with ministers, MPs, peers, parents, schools and professionals to ensure that reform is informed by the realities of children’s lives, rather than simply administrative or financial targets.

Ultimately, success will not be measured by how many plans are removed, how many specialist places are closed or how much money is taken out of the system. It will be measured by whether children receive the education and support they need, whether families have confidence in the system and whether more young people leave school with the skills and opportunities to lead fulfilling, independent lives.

The message in the House of Lords this week was clear; SEND matters, and it matters across party lines. We now need to turn that shared commitment into practical action.

Original source Matthew Elliott: SEND Matters – that’s why protecting specialist education must be part of the reform agenda

Back to home