Maeve Halligan: The higher education delusion

“Education is not the filling of a pail, but the lighting of a fire.” Anyone who has sat in a British classroom may have seen this line emblazoned on the wall, wedged between the clock and a map of the world old enough to include Yugoslavia.

It is a lovely notion — that the point of learning is not to cram young heads with facts, but to spark a curiosity that lasts a lifetime. For a growing number of students, however, the modern British university offers something closer to a damp match, and charges handsomely to boot.

I write as one of the system’s more recent products. I left university in the summer of 2025, aged 22, with an undergraduate degree, and finished an MPhil the following year. For my generation, university was sold not as one path among many but as the only respectable option, and careers advisers rarely mentioned an alternative. It was not always so.

When the Robbins Report was published in 1963, around 4 per cent of young people went to university. Expansion soon became that rarest of things, a cross-party consensus, and in 1999 Tony Blair set a target that half of young people entering higher education. What had once been the preserve of a lucky few would be opened up to the many, or so the promise went. That target has now been met: around 51 per cent enter by the age of 25.

The trouble today is not so much that more young people go to university but that what they find there, and what it is worth, has changed beyond recognition. , a new book from the Institute of Economic Affairs edited by Professor Len Shackleton, is a forensic survey of the cracks in the ivory tower.

The rot is visible first on the balance sheet, with more than a third of universities reporting a deficit for 2024–25. The Office for Students expects more than four in ten to be in the red this year. Money is tight, though notably never so tight that it cannot be found for another research project on equality, diversity and inclusion.

Academic rigour, alas, is a lower priority. The proportion of students awarded a first-class degree has risen from 7 per cent in the early 1990s to 30 per cent today, and not because today’s students are four times cleverer than the Britpop generation. This is grade inflation and, like the monetary kind, it happens when those printing the currency have every reason to print more.

League tables boost the incentive because they reward universities for good degree results, so vice-chancellors have duly encouraged staff to adjust assessments to produce more of them. Little wonder that some employers now skip the degree classification altogether and go straight to the A-level grades.

Universities competing for students have lowered the bar at the door, with 75 per cent of applicants with three Ds at A-level now receiving an offer, up from 61 per cent in 2010. Overseas students, who now supply nearly a quarter of the sector’s income, are treated less as scholars than as walking bursaries, admitted on lower grades and sometimes with too little English to follow the seminars they are paying for.

Invigilated exams have given way to coursework, which tends to earn higher marks, and which ChatGPT can now produce on request for the students finding themselves too beleaguered by the demand that they actually do some work. Universities have yet to catch up, their primary method of ‘regulation’ being empty threats that markers will always recognise if an amenable bot has lent a hefty helping hand.

I watched dozens of my peers hand their assignments over to AI. I have no quarrel with it as a glorified spell-checker, but I could not stomach seeing such a lazy, short-sighted dodge win them perfectly respectable marks without ever requiring a thought of their own. Although, given prevailing campus orthodoxy, this was rarely asked of them anyway.

The decline in the value of a degree, mind you, has by no means been reflected in a price slash. Once the diploma has been gained and the mortarboard tossed in the air, the debt that we grads find ourselves lumbered with brings us crashing back down to earth. A 25-year-old graduate in England can easily owe more than £50,000, and only around a third of recent cohorts are expected to repay in full. The rest can settle in for a thirty-year wait until the balance is written off, paying 9 per cent of everything earnt above the threshold in the meantime.

Meanwhile, the earnings premium for young graduates, the spoonful of sugar meant to help the debt go down, has been shrinking by the year, from about 35 per cent in 2007 to 25 per cent today. In short, for many, the cap and gown route is a very expensive cul-de-sac.

What is to be done? In his chapter of the book, Peter Ainsworth makes a compelling case that the student “” is, in substance, a graduate tax. Its terms are set by the state, can be changed by the state, and have been — the repayment threshold was frozen in 2022, despite an earlier commitment to raise it each year. More damaging still, universities are paid in full and upfront, whether their graduates go on to thrive or to stack shelves. Our higher education institutions bank the dosh, wave their graduates off at the gates and never look back.

What if universities lent to their own students, collecting their income as graduates repaid? Suddenly, every institution would have skin in the game, and courses that lead nowhere would become a liability rather than a cash cow. Unconditional offers and inflated grades would lose their appeal overnight, and the careers service might at last become more than a room full of leaflets. The University of Buckingham has already run a successful scheme on these principles. The question is not whether it can work, but why we keep funnelling young people into a system in which the people taking the money bear none of the risk.

As Alan Milburn’s recent review pointed out, 15 per cent of the one million young people who are currently NEET have degrees. When our unis are handing out firsts like sweets and charging an arm and a leg, one can hardly be shocked when the market stops taking them seriously. Enter the “”, one more year of fees to stand out from a crowd of identical CVs, and the whole cycle threatens to begin again.

A system that will always find the money for another study on inclusion but never the stomach to fail a feeble essay now sends its graduates out with a first that employers have learnt to discount, a debt likely to outlive their career and a portfolio of work ghostwritten by a chatbot. Until universities are made to share in the consequences of what they sell, students will go on paying top price to have their pail filled with nothing but debt.

Original source Maeve Halligan: The higher education delusion

Back to home