Helen Whately: Where Milburn get’s it right we’ll back him but the risk is that Labour will only back the wrong bits

Helen Whately MP is Shadow Secretary of State for Work and Pensions.

No one wants to see Labour’s lost generation spend their lives on welfare. Alan Milburn’s review shows Labour is at last waking up to the problem – after two years of making things worse.

Youth unemployment and the number of NEETs have both gone up since Labour took the helm. Their jobs tax and the Employment Rights Act have killed many thousands of jobs.

Ask any employer and they will tell you.

Their payroll costs have increased punishingly fast. Just the other day a cafe chain told me if they can avoid hiring, they do – and if they hire, they go for someone more experienced. That’s a choice repeated by employers around the country. With 200,000 fewer jobs under this Government, young people have been hit the hardest.

That’s why I’ve lost count of the number of conversations I’ve had with school and university leavers about the demoralising experience of job hunting at the moment. Day after day spent making applications. Usually they hear nothing back.

Just at the moment a young person should be setting out on the first steps of their career, or getting used to earning a regular wage, instead they’re sitting at home. Getting used to being on welfare.

This is a disaster.

That’s why we’ve said, where Milburn gets it right, we’ll back him. For instance, he’s talking about reforming sickness benefits and specifically PIP. Over a year ago we announced that we would stop giving out cash for mild mental health conditions. Treatment and support should be offered instead. In his briefings in advance of publication, it looks like Milburn will recommend exactly this. The only difference so far is that we would do it for all ages, while his recommendations only apply to under 25s.

The hitch for Milburn is that Andy Burnham already criticised this policy as ‘crude cuts’. How then, will he get it past his welfare loving MPs? Conservative votes may be his best hope.

Then we come to the other side of the plan: jobs. I’m afraid this is where Milburn goes wrong. Labour has destroyed jobs with taxes and red tape. The answer is clearly to lighten the load on businesses. But instead, Milburn is proposing thousands of Government subsidised work placements. He may call them jobs, but they are not the real deal. And he’s backing this up with a legal right for every under-25.

Pressed by the BBC’s Laura Kuenssberg on the risk of young people suing the Government for failing to meet this legal obligation he admitted Labour would have to avoid falling into this ‘elephant trap’. Though he didn’t say how. And that’s before we even come to the question of what all this would cost.

The welfare bill is set to exceed £200 billion by 2030. You might expect Alan Milburn to help Andy Burnham come up with some savings. But instead the plan looks likely to cost billions more. A figure of £6 billion has been floated. And again on the Sunday shows, the Welfare Secretary refused to commit to making any welfare savings this Parliament.

We’ve set out how we will make £36.1 billion of savings, and how we will help young people get off welfare and into work. We’ll halve the jobs tax for under 25s, cut business rates for 250,000 high street shops and hospitality businesses, introduce a ‘tough love’ Get to Work programme to stop the drift from education onto benefits, and create 100,000 more apprenticeships for young people every year.

That means thousands more jobs, no option to just sit at home on welfare, and support for young people who’re struggling to meet employers’ expectations.

Original source Helen Whately: Where Milburn get’s it right we’ll back him but the risk is that Labour will only back the wrong bits

Back to home