
Ben Gadsby is a former chairman of Thurrock Conservatives.
The Milburn Review comes in at 278 pages covering welfare and health system (which dominated the headlines) but also education, labour market and employment support.
This breadth is admirable, and to fix the problems of the 2030s we too must work out how education, skills, business and labour market policies fit together into a coherent whole. This must start with a clear view about what we got right and what we got wrong in government.
Laura Trott is right to defend the core of Gove-Gibb education reforms – setting up a what works centre to build the evidence base, and then backing things that were proven to improve English and maths outcomes, like phonics and tutoring.
Low levels of qualification remain too widespread, and are a major predictor of young people neither earning nor learning later on. Our post-covid tutoring catch-up scheme sort of fizzled out, a victim of the ministerial musical chairs of 2022-24, but tutoring is always incredibly popular with parents. We should think about what a more permanent offer looks like for those who fall behind in the basics.
When we return to government, we will need to bring the same rigour and Gibb-like focus to a wider range of work readiness skills. Here, the evidence base has grown since our last stint in opposition. Skills England has recently identified 13 core skills which “allow the competent performance of tasks across different work areas”. Alongside literacy and numeracy are skills like communication, adapting and problem solving, which businesses across the country have identified as challenges in their input to Local Skills Improvement Plans. Too often described as “soft” when they are, in fact, essential, there is a proven link between stronger core skills and higher wages. We should be unapologetic about expecting schools to develop them with the same evidence-driven approach that transformed reading, and championing essential skills as much as we champion technical ones to get more young people into work.
I remember in the long runup to the 2015 election the political advantage in highlighting falling youth unemployment. Every few months, the CCHQ briefings (and Ministers’ Parliamentary answers) would get updated to reflect the latest impressive claim, peaking with the youth claimant count at the lowest since the 1970’s. But today’s challenges are outside the unemployment figures, in disability benefits and in many cases the wider group of economically inactive young people not looking for work at all.
We risk repeating this error if we focus too much on reducing the cost of the benefits system in the short term for headlines sake. At the moment a jobcentre work coach is only allowed to help claimants, so if a young person walks in seeking support the first thing they get is an appointment to make a claim. Understandably, there is zero incentive for getting more people through the doors. If we’re serious about tackling youth worklessness we need to reimagine the entire process – outreach to find people missing from the system (there’s government data that can help, not that anyone ever makes “joined up data” a policy priority), drop-in opportunities for non-claimants to get referred to help, and an acceptance that in the short term this will cost more.
The status quo is penny wise pound foolish and there are things in the Milburn Review we should build on.
And a more supportive system is also, inevitably less punitive in some ways. It’s mad to me that the person supporting a claimant into work is also the person who can sanction their benefits – how easy is it to trust and be open with someone who has that power over you? It doesn’t help that those positive and negative experiences take place in the same physical location either. We could usefully build on the youth hubs we established in government by moving all the supportive functions and staff into them, leaving the more punitive bits of the system in the main jobcentre.
While the systems above must do more to deliver work ready young people into the labour market, we also need employers to do more too. When I was training to be an accountant, my employer would pay for our course fees and give us study leave for exams, with an agreement that we would stay for a set number of months after the course – or pay them back if we left early.
Our flexible labour market is a strength in many ways, but the trade-off is that investment in people is risky for businesses when they can move on easily. As we look to reduce taxes on businesses, we should do so in ways that reward those that do the right thing in terms of investing in people and creating opportunities for people to work part-time, flexibly, and to ramp-up their hours as they transition into the workplace – exactly as we have tried to reform the benefits system to make it easier for people to transition into work and increase their hours. Part of the rationale for a lower apprenticeship minimum wage has been that the apprentice is also receiving the investment in training; what would it look like to require all youth employment to have some form of “minimum investment”; be it a minimum wage, or a lower wage plus a training investment making up the difference?
At the next election, Labour will outcompete us on compassion and Reform will outcompete us on simple answers – as Kemi has pointed out, our winning strategy is to actually have a plan to fix things. While it will require political bravery to lean into the ideas outlined here, Andy Burnham’s approach so far has been vibes-first and it remains to be seen what if anything from Alan Milburn’s report will actually get delivered. But by making serious and detailed proposals, he’s moved the debate onto the territory where Kemi should be at her strongest.
She can’t win on being the person voters most want to watch the football with, but she will win based on the detailed arguments – setting out how we can actually reduce the benefits bill in the long term, actually get the demand for migrant labour down, actually get our economy growing again.
The challenge now is to develop the plan.