UK politics: Andy Burnham pressed on borrowing costs and spending at first PMQs – as it happened

So much for the talk of a new-look PMQs. (See 11.12am.) Although Andy Burnham and his team have spoken about adopting a new approach to the traditional Commons joust with the leader of the opposition, in the end this felt much like business as usual. Burnham was more willing to engage with Kemi Badenoch's questions than Keir Starmer was (certainly in the late Starmer phase), and he did make a point of stressing several times his desire to work with opposition parties. But, although he has made "problem-solving, not point-scoring" his mantra, was quite happy to resort to point-scoring. His main blast was directed at Andrew Griffith, the new shadow chancellor, and his role in the Liz Truss mini-budget.

Burnham may not have been particularly innovative, but he was good; confident, plausible, quite funny. In the exchanges with Badenoch, there was no obvious winner, but he had the best single put-down. That came when asked:

The prime minister told the house that his summer of promises would be paid for by reprioritising within government. So what exactly has he cut?

replied: "In terms of what has he cut? Tax is the simple answer." This was a reference to the point he made yesterday about how his early announcements included two tax cuts in his first week.

While Burnham and Badenoch will both be fairly happy with how the exchanges went, one person less pleased will be the PM's diary secretary. Burnham did seem to agree to a lot of meetings with MPs wanting to discuss this, that or the other. (Starmer would have fobbed them off with a meeting with a minister, which is what Burnham himself will probably be doing before too long.) And this did seem to confirm 's point about Burnham being a people pleaser. (See 12.09pm.) She claimed that, in response to 125 questions yesterday, Burnham did not once say no to a spending request. It is a fair line of attack, although probably not one that will be available for long because Burnham will soon discover that he cannot do this job without having to disappoint.

For a full list of all the stories covered on the blog today, do scroll through the list of key event headlines near the top of the blog.

Andy Burnham at PMQs

At PMQs Kemi Badenoch criticised Labour's record on spending and borrowing. , a Treasury minister, posted this afterwards for clarification.

Some rather crucial context to today's PMQs:

- the last Conservative govt borrowed more than the G7 average in every single one of their 14 years

- this year this govt is… borrowing less, as we also cut borrowing levels faster than any G7 economy

UK borrowing v G7 average

, the journalist and author of excellent books on money laundering and dodgy finance, is not impressed by Nigel Farage's attack on money laundering rules in his interview with the BBC. (See 3.31pm.) He has posted these on Bluesky.

I am not a fan of our AML [anti-money laundering] system but, if someone knows you well enough to know you have a big transaction coming in, and is suspicious enough about it to suspect money laundering, then the bank is probably* right to suspend the account pending enquiries.

I don't want to endlessly factcheck Mr Farage because what would be the point but:

the UK criminalised money laundering in 1988.

the first EU anti-money-laundering directive was in 1991.

I agree with him, incidentally, that UK AML policy is terrible but it is entirely in keeping with the man that he fails to point out that overwhelmingly the largest group of victims of this are blameless Muslims, rather than blowhards in red trousers.

Bullough wrote this long read for the Guardian earlier this year about Muslims being victims of debanking. (In his BBC interview, also complained about how he had been a victim of debanking, suggesting this was another example of anti-money laundering rules being excessive. Farage also said some of his family members had recently suffered "another huge bout of debanking".)

No 10 North's responsibilities for economic growth have been "watered down" and the "real power" remains with the chancellor, the Tories have claimed.

As the Press Association reports, , the shadow Cabinet Office minister who has just been made deputy Tory leader, made the claim as he responded to a Commons statement from Louise Haigh, the first secretary of state, about the government's rewiring the state plans for devolution.

Burghart told MPs he was sympathetic to Burnham's desire to curb the power of the Treasury. He said:

The Treasury, which was the behemoth created in its modern form by Gordon Brown, designed to control Whitehall, designed to reduce department ministers' authority over their spend and over their decisions.

So I was genuinely interested to hear [Haigh] say over the summer that the Treasury was an 'imperial finance department', and I rather hoped that she was going to lead the charge to smash over the barricades and destroy this terrible imperial power.

But instead, it appears that the empire has struck back, because the briefing that we were given initially was that Number 10 North was going to take control of growth.

That seems to have been watered down.

It's now rumoured that the chancellor is going to give the speech on growth next week, and that the real power remains within 'No 11 South'.

So will she tell the house what powers, levers, and budget will she, as head of No 10 North, have to increase growth across the UK?

said functions had been moved from the Treasury to No 10 North, describing it as "a little bit of a chip in its empire". She said:

In terms of the new functions of No 10, we have transferred a number of strategic functions into No 10 North, including moving local economic growth and devolution strategy from the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government and local economic growth policy from HM Treasury.

According to from the Daily Mail, government sources are indicating that Andy Burnham mis-spoke at PMQs when he told Tan Dhesi that he was committed to spending 3% of GDP on defence by 2030. That is not a big surprise because the context implied that, when Burnham said "I've made that commitment", he was actually thinking of 3.5% by 2035 – not the question he had been asked.

Groves says:

Government source confirms Burnham has *not* committed to hit 3% defence spending by 2030, despite appearing to do so at PMQs, saying: 'His position is unchanged'

The Conservative party has now released a full list of shadow ministers, following Kemi Badenoch's reshuffle. from the Spectator has posted the full list on social media.

Kemi Badenoch has just completed her reshuffle. The press release tells us the Conservative Party now has TWENTY members of the Commons whips office. The Conservative Party currently has 118 MPs (6 each). This seems like overkill. Or is she expecting trouble? (Labour has 16 whips for 403 MPs - 25 each)

Here are more pictures of the Just Stop Oil process outside parliament today.

Just Stop Oil protesters blocking the road outside parliament.
Just Stop Oil protest.
Just Stop Oil protest.
Just Stop Oil protest.
The hand of a protester superglued to the road.

, the Reform UK leader, has revealed that his party's bank account has been frozen several times.

In an interview with the BBC's political editor, Chris Mason, Farage said this was evidence Britain has become a "complainant society" where too much time is spent in investigating unfounded allegations.

Farage was responding to a question about why – as the Sunday Times revealed in July – Reform UK had its bank account frozen for two weeks ahead of the 2024 general election over concerns about potentially illegal donations.

Asked why the account was frozen, Farage replied:

That's very common. It's about the fifth time it's happened to us. It happened to us all the time. It happened to us in Ukip [the party Farage led before Brexit]. Happened to us in the Brexit party.

Asked again why this was happening, Farage said:

Because complaints get made! We're living in a complainant society.

You know, if I contact your bank and you've got a big transaction going to your account, and I say I think Chris is money laundering, they will sustain your account, pending an investigation. That's the world we live in.

Some payments to Reform UK are being investigated by the police. Asked in the interview about some specific payments, Farage insisted that they were legitimate.

But he also claimed that rules to counter money laundering were excessive. "A series of European Union directives on money laundering have literally clogged up much of our banking system", he said.

And he argued that Reform UK was subject to particular scrutiny because it was a threat to the establishment.

Asked about the separate investigation by the parliamentary commissioner for standards into claims that he broke Commons rules by not declaring the £5m donation he received before the 2024 general election, Farage indicated that he expected to be interviewed by the commissioner, Daniel Greenberg, in connection with this soon.

Farage indicated that he expected Greenberg to deal with the case fairly. But he implied the Commons standards committee, which will take the final decision about any punishment for breaking Commons rules, was biased against him. "I think we know the outcome already," he said.

When pressed on why he was saying this, he said Reform UK did not have any MPs on the committee, and so all the MP members were political opponents.

The committee does have lay members. But Farage said all members making these sorts of decisions should be "apolitical" – implying he would like the committee to be composed wholly of lay members.

At Westminster it is expected that the committee will rule that Farage did break Commons rules by not declaring the £5m donation and that this was serious enough to merit a suspension of at least 10 days. This would allow a recall byelection to be held in Clacton.

Scotland's first minister has insisted there is "no question" of workers facing compulsory redundancy as he embarks on a programme of major reforms to the public sector, the Press Association reports. PA says:

announced plans in his programme for government that would see the number of area health boards in Scotland cut from 14 at present to just two.

Unions have raised concerns the changes will result in thousands of job losses, with Unite insisting that "all options will be on the table" if needed. [See 10.24am.]

The threat came as the union's general secretary Sharon Graham hit out at the "slash and burn programme for the NHS" that Swinney proposed.

"The proposals will inevitably result in swingeing cuts and thousands of job losses across the public sector," she added.

Swinney however insisted the Scottish government would "work very closely" with unions as it embarks on the changes.

When he announced the changes to MSPs on Tuesday, the first minister said they were "the most radical reshaping of public services" in Holyrood's history.

And speaking today he insisted the country needs to not only "change the way in which we deliver public services to make sure they are sustainable", but also needs to reduce the public sector workforce.

With the Scottish government facing a budget black hole of almost £5bn by the end of the decade, the SNP leader said: "I have said that for all the time I have been first minister there will be a need for public sector employment to fall."

Stressing that the government has to "live in the realities of the financial situation that we face" he told BBC Radio Scotland's breakfast programme that "it is likely over the next few years that there will be a reduction in public sector employment".

He refused to estimate how many jobs could go as a result of the changes – which will also see a new structure set up for Scotland's councils.

Swinney was clear he was not going to "put particular numbers on this" with regard to job losses.

But he insisted that ministers would "work collaboratively" with the unions as the country moves "toward the two-board approach".

The first minister also insisted the government's policy of no compulsory redundancies within the public sector would be maintained.

Here is 's story from PMQs.

So much for the talk of a new-look PMQs. (See 11.12am.) Although Andy Burnham and his team have spoken about adopting a new approach to the traditional Commons joust with the leader of the opposition, in the end this felt much like business as usual. Burnham was more willing to engage with Kemi Badenoch's questions than Keir Starmer was (certainly in the late Starmer phase), and he did make a point of stressing several times his desire to work with opposition parties. But, although he has made "problem-solving, not point-scoring" his mantra, was quite happy to resort to point-scoring. His main blast was directed at Andrew Griffith, the new shadow chancellor, and his role in the Liz Truss mini-budget.

Burnham may not have been particularly innovative, but he was good; confident, plausible, quite funny. In the exchanges with Badenoch, there was no obvious winner, but he had the best single put-down. That came when asked:

The prime minister told the house that his summer of promises would be paid for by reprioritising within government. So what exactly has he cut?

replied: "In terms of what has he cut? Tax is the simple answer." This was a reference to the point he made yesterday about how his early announcements included two tax cuts in his first week.

While Burnham and Badenoch will both be fairly happy with how the exchanges went, one person less pleased will be the PM's diary secretary. Burnham did seem to agree to a lot of meetings with MPs wanting to discuss this, that or the other. (Starmer would have fobbed them off with a meeting with a minister, which is what Burnham himself will probably be doing before too long.) And this did seem to confirm 's point about Burnham being a people pleaser. (See 12.09pm.) She claimed that, in response to 125 questions yesterday, Burnham did not once say no to a spending request. It is a fair line of attack, although probably not one that will be available for long because Burnham will soon discover that he cannot do this job without having to disappoint.

protesters are blockading the road outside parliament, Kate Ferguson from the Sun on Sunday reports.

Just Stop Oil protesters outside parliament.

During PMQs , the Labour chair of the Commons defence committee, asked Burnham if he would commit to raising defence spending to 3% of GDP by 2030.

He said:

It is imperative that we invest in our armed forces in the here and now, rather than be sorry later. Indeed, defence is definitely one area where vibes alone just isn't going to be enough.

So rather than kick the can down the road waiting for a fiscal event in the future, will the prime minister urgently commit to charting a pathway to reach 3% of GDP spend on defence by 2030, which, as his chancellor rightly noted, is critical to keep our country safe.

John Healey resigned as defence secretary when Keir Starmer was PM because Starmer would not commit to raising defence spending to 3% of GDP by 2030. He is now chancellor, but has not publicly committed to reaching the 3% target he insisted was essential by 2030.

In reply, said:

I've made that commitment, made it very clear, and I have done for a considerable period of time. And I was in Ukraine last week for a very specific reason to repeat it on the world stage. There [Dhesi] can be absolutely sure of that.

This sounded like a clear commitment to 3% by 2030.

But there was some doubt about his intention because earlier during the exchanges, when Kemi Badenoch said that the armed forces needed a plan to hit 3% now, Burnham in reply just repeated the commitment to get defence spending up to 3.5% by 2035. (See 12.18pm.)

According to from the Daily Mail, government sources are indicating that Andy Burnham mis-spoke at PMQs when he told Tan Dhesi that he was committed to spending 3% of GDP on defence by 2030. That is not a big surprise because the context implied that, when Burnham said "I've made that commitment", he was actually thinking of 3.5% by 2035 – not the question he had been asked.

Groves says:

Government source confirms Burnham has *not* committed to hit 3% defence spending by 2030, despite appearing to do so at PMQs, saying: 'His position is unchanged'

(Lab) tells Burnham that this is her first question at a PMQs too. Niblett is the MP who made headlines with her "summer of sex" campaign, and she says he has had a tremendous response to it. She says:

I have discovered that shame, guilt and embarrassment around talking about sex and body parts like penis and vagina is even leading to late diagnosis of health conditions and illnesses such as cancer.

She asks if Burnham will meet her to discuss her campaign.

says he will. He says Niblett has been raising important issues, and he jokes that her summer sounds as if it was more exciting than his.

And that is the end of Burnham's first PMQs.

, who has just been appointed as Kemi Badenoch's PPS, says Burnham did not answer any of Badenoch's questions. He asks if Burnham can say what the fiscal rules are, and categorically say he will stick to them.

replies:

No borrowing to fund day to day spending, debt falling as a percentage of GDP by the end of the parliament. And yes, we will.

Original source UK politics: Andy Burnham pressed on borrowing costs and spending at first PMQs – as it happened

Back to home