America or Europe: sovereignty subordinated or shared?

Now that the question of returning to a closer partnership with our European neighbours is again actively under public discussion, Liberal Democrats should tackle the underlying assumptions of the unreconciled right.  For them, Brexit was not about reasserting British sovereignty as such.  It was about reasserting Anglo-Saxon leadership, about pushing back the social democracy and state intervention that characterised continental Europe and clinging to our partnership with the United States – seeing Americans as our cousins and the USA as a country of free markets and minimal state intervention, a model that they wanted Britain to follow. 

It’s long since been clear that Boris Johnson’s assertions that favourable trade agreements with the USA would be easy to negotiate and would replace our dependence on the EU were pie in the sky.  We’ve since discovered that the ‘special’ relationship isn’t very special to the US Administration and most Congressmen, and that NATO looks less and less like a viable alternative to closer European security cooperation.  The US economy has been growing strongly, driven by massive Silicon Valley investment, but it has also been growing more and more unequal, with the proceeds of growth flowing to a tiny minority.

One of the cries of Nigel Farage and his colleagues was that British sovereignty was threatened by sharing legislation and regulation with other EU members.  Boris Johnson conjured up a world in which Britain would again become a global power, with naval ships in the Pacific and partnerships with the USA and China.  Behind this lay an underlying assumption that Britain should become more like America, and that accepting US rules and regulations on finance, technology and trade did not undermine UK sovereignty.  (I recall being reprimanded by a Conservative peer, who asserted that ‘we do not regard American rules as infringing our sovereignty’.)  But in the ten years since the Referendum, assumptions in Britain have changed. 

 Even Conservatives now worry about dependence on US satellites and social media.  Intelligence and military links with the USA remain close, but it’s clear that in all other fields Britain is not a privileged partner of the USA, and that US Administrations – responding to an electorate that now looks to Latin America and Asia as much as to Europe – are no longer reliable partners for Britain.  In a world dominated by great power rivalry between China, the USA and Russia, it’s strongly in our national interest to share sovereignty with our neighbours rather than bounce uncomfortably along behind the US President and Congress.

The House of Lords is currently discussing American interference in British politics as part of its scrutiny of the Representation of the People Bill.  The US State Department now has a fund for supporting free speech and ‘civilisational values’ as the Trump Administration defines them; several right-wing think tanks and NGOs have applied for support.  Ultra-conservative foundations and ultra-wealthy Americans have been funding their favoured disrupters.  Elon Musk is reported to have paid the legal costs of Tommy Robinson’s defence in recent court cases; Robert Shillman, another US funder of the international hard right, has been underwriting his lifestyle.  The illiberal values this flow of American money is trying to promote echo in British politics.  Danny Kruger wants to take us back to ‘traditional’ roles for men and women.  James Orr, briefly Reform’s head of policy, has like Kruger been closely engaged with such US-founded organizations as the Conservative Political Action Conference and the Edmund Burke Foundation.

Nostalgia for a lost white Anglo-Saxon world links the British and American hard right. Jacob Rees-Mogg represents the most archaic and ethnic version of Anglo-Saxondom.  His 878 Foundation is named after the battle of Edington, in which King Alfred threw back the Danes.  Next year commemoration of the 1100 anniversary of the incorporation of Viking Northumbria into Alfred’s kingdom by his grandson Athelstan, seen by some historians as ‘the creation of England’.  Behind this lies the historical myth that Anglo-Saxon England was a country of free citizens in which the Witan served as a proto-Parliament – destroyed after 150 years by the tyrannical Norman invasion.  Daniel Hannan’s book, , claims that ‘the English-speaking peoples’ alone created the model of a free society and a limited state, and took it across the Atlantic from its English roots.  In such an imagined world America and England belong together against the world – and particularly the European continent, from where the Normans invaded.

This is discredited history, tied to an image of the USA when it was ruled by ‘White Anglo-Saxon Protestants’, which arguably remained the case until 60-70 years ago.  Now the Latino vote is an important factor, Mississippi has elected a black senator and Michigan a Muslim one, ethnically diverse California and Texas outweigh Massachusetts and Virginia, and Americans look across the Pacific and south to Latin America far more than to England, or even Europe as a whole.  In an increasingly insecure world, with economic imbalances and rivalries disrupting the global economy, the choice that Britain faces is between following US demands and regulations from administration to administration or sharing our sovereignty with our European partners.  That, after all, is what Geoffrey Howe argued, in spite of Margaret Thatcher’s hesitations, 40 years ago.  We should be throwing the argument at the Brexiteeers as they return to their old themes.

* William Wallace is LibDem peer, a former vice-chair of the Federal Policy Committee and convenor of the party's 1997 manifesto team.

Original source America or Europe: sovereignty subordinated or shared?

Back to home